Pro Evolution Soccer 2018: A Flawed but Beloved Football Sim

Pro Evolution Soccer 2018 (PES 2018), released in 2017 by Konami, remains a significant entry in the long-running football simulation series. While subsequent iterations have refined the formula, PES 2018 holds a special place in the hearts of many fans, representing a compelling blend of fluid gameplay, strategic depth, and – despite its imperfections – a genuinely enjoyable football experience. This review will delve into the game’s strengths and weaknesses, exploring why it continues to resonate with players even years after its release.

Fluid Gameplay and Strategic Depth

At its core, PES 2018 is an exercise in controlled precision. The game’s deliberate pacing encourages strategic thinking and tactical planning, rewarding players who carefully consider their moves. Unlike some arcade-style football games, PES 2018 prioritizes skillful execution over frantic button mashing. This deliberate approach allows for a more nuanced and rewarding experience, where the outcome hinges on strategic decision-making and precise control of players.

The game mechanics facilitate intricate maneuvers, providing players with the tools to execute complex passes, dribbles, and shots. This sense of control over individual players and the overall flow of the game fosters a feeling of genuine involvement and empowers players to dictate the match’s tempo and direction. The responsiveness of the players and the physics engine contribute to a fluid and engaging gameplay experience that continues to hold up well against more modern titles. Even experienced players will find the game’s nuances challenging and rewarding, while newer players will find a gradual learning curve that allows them to develop their skills at their own pace.

Diverse Game Modes and Immersive Features

PES 2018 offers a generous variety of game modes catering to diverse player preferences. The Master League, a staple of the PES franchise, allows players to step into the shoes of a football manager, guiding their chosen team through seasons, navigating transfer markets, and shaping the club’s identity. The Become a Legend mode provides a different perspective, letting players create their own footballer and chart their path from youth player to international superstar. These modes offer extensive opportunities for long-term engagement and strategic depth beyond single matches.

In addition to these single-player modes, PES 2018 includes robust online features for competitive multiplayer action. While the servers might not be as active as they once were, the opportunity for head-to-head matches remains a significant draw for many players. The online element adds a layer of dynamism and unpredictability to the experience, fostering a sense of community and competition. Beyond the core modes, the game features a soundtrack that reflects the musical trends of 2018, offering a diverse selection of hip-hop, dancehall, pop, and other genres to enhance the overall atmosphere.

Visuals and Audio: A Mixed Bag

PES 2018, built on Konami’s Fox Engine, delivered impressive visuals for its time. While graphical technology has progressed significantly since its release, the game still holds up remarkably well, particularly on higher settings. The player models, stadiums, and overall presentation retain a level of detail that remains pleasing to the eye. The attention to detail in player animations and the realism of ball physics contributes to the overall immersion. However, the visual quality can vary depending on hardware and settings, and some graphical elements might appear dated compared to more modern titles.

On the audio front, however, PES 2018 falls somewhat short. The commentary, a frequent criticism of PES titles, suffers from repetition and a lack of enthusiasm. While it doesn’t completely detract from the gameplay, the repetitive nature of the commentary can become jarring over extended periods of play, particularly for players who invest significant time in the various game modes. The soundtrack, while diverse, might not appeal to every player and, depending on one’s taste, could be seen as a minor contribution to the overall enjoyment of the game.

Licensing and Control Issues: Significant Drawbacks

Despite its considerable strengths, PES 2018 is hampered by two significant limitations. The most prominent issue is licensing. The game notoriously suffers from a lack of officially licensed teams and kits, necessitating the use of generic names and designs for many clubs. This is a considerable drawback for many football fans who crave authenticity and the accurate representation of their favorite teams. The absence of licensed teams not only diminishes the immersion, but it also affects the overall presentation and can feel jarring for players accustomed to the detailed licensing of other football simulators.

The second major flaw concerns controller support, or rather, the lack thereof for mouse and keyboard input. PES 2018 is fundamentally designed for controller use, and attempting to navigate the game using a mouse and keyboard is notoriously cumbersome and frustrating. The game’s interface and controls are not optimized for this input method, making it practically unplayable for those who prefer not to use a controller. This significantly limits the game’s accessibility for some PC players, reducing the overall player base and potentially discouraging casual gamers.

A Lasting Legacy: Why PES 2018 Remains Relevant

Despite its flaws – the licensing issues, repetitive commentary, and limited keyboard support – PES 2018 remains a noteworthy and enjoyable football simulator. Its strengths, particularly its fluid gameplay, strategic depth, and the variety of game modes, compensate to a considerable extent for its weaknesses. The game offers a unique experience that prioritizes skill, strategy, and player control, setting it apart from more arcade-style football games. Many players find its gameplay superior to that of its contemporaries, particularly appreciating the game’s responsiveness and overall sense of control.

The enduring popularity of PES 2018 among a dedicated fanbase attests to its merits. Even years after its release, the game retains a sizable community of players who value its unique gameplay mechanics and the opportunities presented by its various game modes. This longevity suggests that for many, the game’s strengths outweigh its shortcomings, solidifying its position as a noteworthy and fondly remembered title in the PES series. Its relative simplicity compared to modern iterations makes it accessible to players who may not have the time or inclination to master the complexities of newer games.

Conclusion: A Nostalgic Trip or a Worthwhile Investment?

Pro Evolution Soccer 2018 is a game that stands as a testament to the evolution of the football simulation genre. It offers a unique gameplay experience, albeit one marred by several limitations. Whether it’s a worthwhile addition to your game library in 2024 depends on your priorities. If you value fluid, strategic gameplay above all else, and you have a game controller, then PES 2018 might offer a compelling and nostalgic experience. However, the lack of licensing, repetitive commentary, and the problematic keyboard/mouse control make it a less ideal choice for those who prioritize realism, authenticity, or who prefer to play using keyboard and mouse controls. Ultimately, it serves as a reminder of what made the PES series so beloved and provides a glimpse into the evolution of the series over time. Its legacy isn’t about perfect execution, but rather a potent blend of skillful gameplay and a unique feel that continues to resonate with its fanbase.